Google This is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for generations on library shelves before it was carefully scanned by Google as part of a project to make the world's books discoverable online. It has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subject to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that's often difficult to discover. Marks, notations and other maiginalia present in the original volume will appear in this file - a reminder of this book's long journey from the publisher to a library and finally to you. Usage guidelines Google is proud to partner with libraries to digitize public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order to keep providing tliis resource, we liave taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties, including placing technical restrictions on automated querying. We also ask that you: + Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Google Book Search for use by individuals, and we request that you use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes. + Refrain fivm automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort to Google's system: If you are conducting research on machine translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help. + Maintain attributionTht GoogXt "watermark" you see on each file is essential for in forming people about this project and helping them find additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it. + Keep it legal Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries. Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Google Book Search means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liabili^ can be quite severe. About Google Book Search Google's mission is to organize the world's information and to make it universally accessible and useful. Google Book Search helps readers discover the world's books while helping authors and publishers reach new audiences. You can search through the full text of this book on the web at|http: //books .google .com/I ': e .■■ .; . * *f 4 ■ • ■• *-■.'■ *. •■ ' . « / • i r : c ■■ . . ■ .^-^v. I / • ^ I /"€! ■> ri -i'^si HISTORY American Odd Fellowship THE FIRST DECADE. JAMES L RIDGELY, H ISTOR I OGRAPH ER . SIXTH THOUSAND. BALTIMORE, MD,: BV JAMES L. KIDCELV, r.V AUTHORITV ()K THE GRAND LODGK Of THK UNITKIl STATKS I 1878 i-r^^s'' \ . J Entered according to Act of Conj^ress, in tlie year One Thousand Kl.udit Hundred and Sevonty-eight, by ^ - 1^* JAMES L. lUDGELY, in the Office of the Librarian of Congress, at Washington. All rights reserved. ELE(Tl{OTYPEI» DY ritlNTKr> HY JOHN RYAN & CO.. JOHN L. MIKPHY. Baltimore. Trouton.N.J. TO THE Right Worthy Grand Lodge of the United States, OF THE INDEPENDENT ORDER OF ODD FELLOWS. TO WHICH, MORE THAN TO ANY OTHER HUMAN AGENCY, MANKIND OWES THE GRANDEST SYSTEM OF SECULAR AFFILIATED BENEVOLENCE OF ANY AGE, THIS WORK IS AFFECTIONATELY DEDICATED. HONOR, PERPETUITY AND BLESSINGS are forever due to its grand and subordinate organizations, for zeal and devotion in the cause; but to its paternal govern- ment and wise and judicious administration, is the present wondrous development to be chiefly ascribed. Great is the leader of a forlorn hope to victory ; great the pilot who steers his precious freight safely through the storm and tempest; but greater the genius that evokes from the rough marble, the master- PIECE OF ART AND BEAUTY — THE DiVINE ImaGE IN HUMANITY. PREFACE This book goes forth as the history of the first decade of American Odd Fellowship, by James L. Ridgely, Grand Corres- ponding and Recording Secretary, and also Historiographer of the Grand Lodge of the United States, I. O. O. F. As its prep- aration has been connected with several other names as State Historiographers, from whom some material has been derived, the extent of such aid will be fully acknowledged. The particu- lar connection of Hon. Henry F. Garey with the publication, deserves special mention, which is now given. When this history was first proposed, such was the condition of my health, that in view of contingencies which were obvious, I sought the aid of competent brothers to assist me in the task. My first application was to Bro. Rev. E. H. Chapin of New York, P. G. M.; Reps. Morse of California, P. G. M.; Harmon of California, P. G. M., and Garey of Maryland, P. G. M. These all, at that time, declined the invitation, and I remained alone in the enterprise. Afterwards, Bro. Garey was induced to join me, and has been identified with me in every stage of the book's progress, until its conclusion. Our labor has been joint ; the original text has undergone a revision, in which each has given his personal consideration to the topics discussed. In one particular I have taken no counsel and stand alone. The comments on the men, the policy and the principles of the Order, express my individual sentiments long held on those subjects, and in that sense are entirely my own. My part has been to collect and suggest from the mass of material at hand, and to designate its use ; to correct false history, to bring together new facte, to present the traits and labors of the known historic men of the Order, and to see that the honors should be appropriately awarded. Occasionally, also, in the rendition of legislative texts, to furnish the proper key to the enactments and proceedings, which Vi PREFACE. otherwise were hidden in a dry and barren record. My colleague is the Editor ; I regard such appellation as his appropriate title. He has also supervised the style and language of the whole man- uscript, including my own, although much has been inserted lit- erally as it was supplied by my hand. When it is known that Judge Garey has fully performed his duties in the Court of Common Pleas of Baltimore City, during the whole period of his connection with this work, it will be acknowledged that he has acquitted himself to the history with fidelity. Whatever defects or omissions may exist in the volume, will find an ample excuse in the circumstances under which it was written. The whole book so fully expresses my personal views on all the subjects treated, that I accept its authorship without reserve, and for all its contents assume the sole responsibility. It was to me the work was committed. It contains my cherished opinions of the Order and its principles. So far as frail humanity would permit, it is a truthful and complete statement of the great matters of which it treats. It is the depository of my hopes and fears, and of my love for the institution with which my life has been identified since manhood, and my name associated for nearly half a century. I have sought to portray to the brethren the transactions and the men of the first decade, with whom I have been in part contemporaneous, with strict impartiality. No reliable source of information from which light could be thrown upon that eventful period has escaped my research. The manu- scripts of Bro. Kennedy, P. G. S., have been placed at my disposal. These I have found invaluable as the proper oracles of the times. I have used them largely as the public property, giving special credit only where special quotations have been made from them. The researches of John W. Stokes and William Ellison, re- spectively, in Pennsylvania and Massachusetts, have enabled me to present interesting chapters on those States. In so doing I have closely followed them so far as the plan of the work per- mitted. Past Grand Sire Ellison's production was very satisfac- tory, and I hereby tender my sincere thanks to the Board of Grand Oflicers of the Grand Lodge of Massachusetts for the generous do- nation of a copy free of expense. The work of Grand Sire Stokes is of great value, and is exhaustive of the subject. As far as was PREFACE. Vii possible bis plan of treatment has been adopted. That veteran Odd Fellow has been identified with the leaders in the Order for thirty- five years, having entered the Grand Lodge of the United States in 1843. His labors include a full review of the Patriarchal Brancii, which few if any were equally competent to furnish. Its history in Pennsylvania is full of interest. But as that branch of the Order grew out of the degrees called Patriarchal, as the higher penetralia of Odd Fellowship, we have been forced to confine its history to the chapter on that subject. His contribution is deserving of special mention, and might well be published as a separate volume, which would be very attractive in that great jurisdiction. The chapter on New York would have been unsatisfactory but for the valuable assistance of P. G. Rep. John Medole, of that jurisdiction, and I am greatly indebted to P. G. Sire William "W. Moore of the District of Columbia, not only for in- formation about that locality, but for important matter in the chapter on the degrees. The illustrations have been obtained at great labor and expense, and but for the aid of zealous friends would be in- complete. As it is, we regret the absence of several which it was not possible for us to obtain. We gladly return our acknowledg- ments to Bros. Porter and Ford of Massachusetts, G. Sire Stokes of Pennsylvania, Bro. Medole of New York, Bro. Parker of New Jersey, Bro. Havenner of the District of Columbia, and Bro. McKelvey of West Virginia, for their kind attentions in this de- partment of the work. The design for the beautiful emblematic device on the cover of the book, was prepared about a year ago by our lamented Brother Fred. D. Stuart, P. G. Sire, who mani- fested a great interest in this publication. The work has gone to press under the supervision of Bro. Theodore A. Boss, Assis- tant Grand Secretary, whose services have greatly lightened the labors of the author and editor. And now, my brethren, having assigned to all concerned proper credit in the production of this work, my task is about to close. One word more and I have done. My days of prac- tical usefulness are passing away; I cannot much longer mingle in the councils of the Order. Certainly I can no longer write and speak for the institution as in days gone by. This doubtless is my last effort to serve Odd Fellowship. It is my Vlll PREFACE. last tribute to that great and good cause — ray farewell to that loving band of brothers throughout the world, who have so warmly greeted me ever since they learned to honor and revere the Order. In the hope that it may do good service for Human- ity and Fraternity, I commit it to the Brotherhood. JAMES L. RIDGELY. CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. PAOK Ihtroduction 1 The Order founded on principles. — Its name. — Not a borrower. — Oppo- sition.— Origin of Odd Fellowship. — Records. — ^The Manchester Unity. How materials were obtained for the history. — The close of the reign of Wildey. — ^Plan of treatment. CHAPTER II. Washinoton Lodge, No. 1 15 American Odd Fellowship. — Wildey and Welch. — ^Washington Lodge instituted. — The English work. — Jackson the rival of Wildey. — ^P. G. Crowder's mission. — ^The original charter from Duke of York's Lodge. John Yates* mission. — Finances. — The benefit system. — Wildey pre- ferred to Jackson. — ^Franklin Lodge to supersede Washington Lodge. Committee of Past Grands. — The American Degrees. — The P. G.*s of Washington Lodge become the G. L. of Md. and of the U. S. — A Con- stitution adopted.— " The Seven Stars."— " The Three Loggerheads." Stillhouse Lane.— Matthew Blakeley*s;— May 1822.— The Convivial feature.— The Maryland Reform.— The Host.— Odd Fellow's Ameral. Columbia Lodge, No. 8. — Joshua Vansant. — Colvin's Stone Tavern. Wildey's house. — Washington Lodge in 1821 , and its present condition. CHAPTER III. John Boyd 67 His nativity. — His employments. — He Joins Washington Lodge. — Assists in establishing the G. L. of Md. and of the U. S.— First G. Guardian and G. Treasurer. — One of the first to receive the Golden Rule Degree. Assists to organize the G. L. of the U. 8. — ^Proxy for Pennsylvania, also Delaware. — Is known as The Past Grand. — A lover of ancient usage. — A Stockholder in the Gay Street Hall. — Becomes wealthy. His devotion to Washington Lotlge. — Last public appearance. — His death. — The medal presented to him. CHAPTER IV. The G. Lodge of Md. and of the U. S 6C^ Its organization and first proceedings. — Charter to Franklin Lodge, No. 2. — Constitution adopted. — Address of Wildey. — The Boston let- CONTENTS. PAeK tor.— Grant of charters to Mass.— Wlldey's mission.— Applications fVom N. York and Penna.— The odes and tunes.— Medal to G. Sec. Entwisle.— Constitution of Nov. 1828.— Columbia Lodge, No 3.— Proxies to forma G. L. of U. 8.— Financial condition.— Report on for- mation of a G. Lodge of U. 8.— Circular.— Death of G. Sec. Entwisle. Constitution forG. L. of U. 8. — Election for officers G. Lodge of Md. A medal to Wildey.— The G. Lodge of Md. and of the U. S. adjourns tiM die, — Reflections. CHAPTER V. John Welch 101 One of the trio. — His history before 1819. — One of the original five. — First Vice Grand.— Wildey's counsellor.— First G. Sec. of G. L. of Md. and of the U. S.— First D. G. S. of the G. L. U. S.— The Mentor and Nestor of the enterprise. CHAPTER VI. Thb Grand Lodge op Maryland 108 Its charter. — The theory of its origin. — Charles Conmion, G. M. — Seeks to become a corporate body. — Anniversaries. — Assets. —Degrees and Sunday — Trials. — Political resolutions afterwards expunged. — Reflec- tions.— The present flag procured. —Thomas Scotchbum G. M. — The sitting G. M. to be Rep. to G. L. U. S. — This law repealed. — The Patriarchal Degree and a crozier.— The new signs. — Honorary membership. — Charges and degrees in German. — The Germans in I. O.O.F. — Order and price of Degrees. — A conunon lodge-room. — Ori- gin of the Encampment Branch. — Reports of Subordinates. — Visiting cards. — Of a G. Treasurer. — Incorporation obtained by Ridgely and others.— Resolutions and presentation to Ridgely and Keyser. — " Giv- ing the Honors" abolished.— Gratitude Lodge, No. 6.— An Odd Fel- lows* Hall to be built.— James L. Ridgely becomes G. Sec. — Ilis part in obtainmg the hall— Description of Wildey's Odd Fellows' Hall. The new initiates. — Prominent names. — Difficulty of procuring an auditorium. — Rev. J. V. Bartow. — Gratitude.— The orators Ridgely and Walsh. — The Press. — Condusiou. CHAPTER VII. Augustus Mathiot 149 The Young American. — His birth and parentage. — His characteristics. He joins the Order.— Masonry and Odd Fellowship in 1823.— The Ma- ryland reform. — Temperance in 1823.— D. G. Master and G. Master. G. Secretary and G. Treasurer of G. L. U. S.— The second G. Patri- arch.— His success in business and liberality. — A gi*een old age. — His death and the Three Odd Links. CONTENTS. XI CHAPTER VIII. PAGB Richard Marley 161 Introduction. — Odd Fellowship a field of labor. — His history and work. Initiated in Franklin Lodge. — Proxy for N. York. — His early failing. Fifth degree members and the spurious lodge. — Expelled and retiu-ns. His reformation. — G. Master and G. Patriarch. — His career in the G. L. U. 8. — ^Veneiftblo Warden. — His devotion and influence. — Rare traits of character. — Death of a great Odd Fellow. — His splendid fune- ral.— His Portrait. CHAPTER IX. The Grand Lodge op the United States 173 The unity of tlie &mily arrangement. — Its constitution.— A representa- tive body. — Met at Wildey's. — Reflections. — A question of jurisdic- tion.— The oixler of the degrees. — Maryland not to be its ]>crmanent seat. — Arrival of the Patriarchal Degi'ce. — Title of M. W. G. Sire. — The price of the degrees. — Wildey's report of his visit to England. — English charter of 1820. — The American degrees in England. — Cer- tificates and Cards. — New charter to G. Lodge of Pennsylvania. — Central Lodge, No. 1, and Georgetown Lodge, No. 2, of the District of Columbia chartered. — Old and new signs. — Engrossed thanks to the Q. Sire for his visit to England. — The Movable Committee. — The name and initials of the Order. — G. Lodge of the District of Columbia chartered. — The Order in 1829. — Augustus Mnthiot G. Sec— Mass. declining. — Encampments. — Friendly Union Lodge, No. 1, R. Island. John Welch, D. G. Sire, retires.— Thos. Scotchbum, D. Q. 6.— The ^ Order in 1830.— The G. L. of Penn. sustained.— The Movable Com- mittee a failure — Ohio Lodge, No. 1, chartered. — Personal govern- ment.— Eulogy of the founder. — G. Sec. James L. Ridgely as Q. Repre- sentative.— The devotion of Wildcy and Ridgely. — The Order in 1881. Funeral ceremonies. — The literature of the Ortler. — ^The G. Lodge of Ohio. — The G. Encampment of Maryland. — Reflections. — Wildey En- campment, No. 1, at N. Orleans. — G. Lodge of Louisiana. — A libel on the G. Sire. — Boone Lodge, No. 1, at Louisville. — James Gettys, G. Sire.— The Order in 1832.— Meeting of the G. Lodge in Philadelphia. Resolutions and presentation to Wildey. — How procured. — Augus- tus Mathiot, G. Treas. — Farewell Address. — Reflections. — Review of the condition of the Order down to 1833. — Twelve propositions. — Conclusion. CHAPTER X. John Pawson Entwisle 237 The intellectual and literary member.— Entwisle before ho found Wil- dey.— The deviser of the Representative system. — His style. — Author of the Covenant and Remembrance Degrees. — The Covenant Degree vindicated and analyzed. — Tlie second D. G. M. — Grand S<»crotary. — Sudden death. — The presiding genius of the Oixler. — His fame as- sured.— Conclusion. Xll CONTENTS. CHAPTER XI. PAGS The Secret Principle 250 Introductory. — Mystery. — The Ancient Mysteries. — Antiquity of the secret principle. — Doctrines and Rites. — The Eleusininn mysteries. — The Egjrptian school. — China, Japan, Britain, Gaul and Scandinavia. Greece. — Influence of the mysteries on the modems. — Odd Fellow- ship an original. — Ancient mysteries in modern forms. — The doc- trines and rites of Pythagoras. — Free Masonry. — Idolatry and My- thology.— Truth will linally prevaiL CHAPTER XII. Thomas Wildet 275 How a biography should be written. — The central figure of the Great Trio. — Wildey before 1819. — He institutes Washington Lodge. — His version of the narrative. — The founder of Odd Fellowship. — Analysis of his character. — His boundless devotion. — His affecting farewell. — As travelling missionary. — His tour and his great success. — Wildey the Patriarch. — His later history and greeu old age. — The death of the founder. — Conclusion. CHAPTER XIII. Tbb Degrees and Encampment Branch 29^ The early English work. — The White, Blue and Scarlet Degrees. — Terms. — First appearance of the Golden Rule Degree. — Upon whom conferred. — Ritual of Washington Lodge. — ^The American Degrees. — The Royal Purple Degree.— The Past Official Degrees.— The Grand Lodge Degree. — The Patiiarchal Degree. — An Encampment Lodge. Encampment of Patriarchs. — Chai'ter of the first Encampment of Pa- triarchs.— Encampments in Penn. — New York and Mass. — Wildey took the responsibility. — Acknowledged by the G. L. U. S. -The En- campment Branch. — Obtains representation in the G. L. of U. S. — Maryland followed by the other States. — Great success. — Uniformed Patriarchs. — G. Encampment Degree and Honorary Degree of P. C. P. and P. H. P. — The lectures or ritual. — First printed American lecture- book. — Successive reprints. — The revision of 1835. — Revision of 1845. The unwritten Work. — The secret Joiunal. — The Hailing Sign, the Sign of Recognition and the Degree of Rebekah. — Degree Lodges. Tlie Traveling Password. — Anti-Masonry and the obligation. — Con- clusion. CHAPTER XIV. Odd Fellowship in Massachusetts. 881^ Introduction. — John B. Barnes. — His English Medal. — His coadjutors. Mass. Lodge instituted. — Barnes the first N. G. — Siloam Lodge insti- CONTENTS. XIU PAOB tated. — A letter from Md. — Barnes* career. — His departure for Vir- ginia.— ^Medal and tokens of respect. — His death and burial. — ^Bro. Wildon's visit to Baltimore. — Wildey delivers a legal charter to Mass. Lodge. — Copy of the charter. — A G. Lodge instituted. — History of Mass. Lodge, No. 1. — Siloam Lodge, No. 2. — Its charter. — James Wood. — Thomas Ban*. — George Ashworth. — Good Samaritan Lodge, No. 3.— New England Lodge, No. 4.— P. G. M. Thomas F. Norris.— Simeon Southwick. — Joseph Lopez. — Washington Lodge, No. 5. — Adam Lodge, No, 6.— Merrimac Lodge, No. 7. — Smnmary and con- clusion. CHAPTER XV. Thb Grand Lodgb of Massachusetts. S09 Action of the G. L. U. S.— Its charter.— Daniel Hersey, first G. M.— First general laws. — ^Public procession and installation at Taunton. — Mer- rimac Lodge, No. 7. — Correspondence with Wildey. — William Bishop, G. M. — Josiah Robinson, G. M. — Visit of the Movable Committee of G. L. U. S. — Albert Guild becomes a member in 1831. — His history. He restores the Order. — Wildey appears. — The circumstances of the decadence of the old G. Lodge. — ^Reflections. — The grand success that followed the revival CHAPTER XVI. Odd Fellowship in New York 393 Introduction. — The Chambers family. — They institute Shakespeare Lodge. — Morris and Flanagan. — ^Franklin, Washington, and Co- lumbia Lodges. — Columbia Lodge obtains a legal charter. — Contro- versy with Franklin Lodge. — Charter of Columbia Lodge. — Wildey decides in favor of tJolumbia Lodge. — Columbia Lodge accepts a char- ter from G. Lodge of Md, and U. S. — Benjamin Downing. — Charter of G. Lodge of New York. — Jno. B. Robinson, G. M. — ^Friendship Lodge, No. 2. — Hope Lodge, No. 8. — Strangers* Refuge Lodge, No. 4. — Is expelled and becomes a spurious G. Lodge. — The ancient members and organization. — Philanthropic Lodge, No. 5. — Strangers' Refuge Lodge restored. — Its singular history. — The G. Lodge has its last meeting In 1828. — The change in 1830. — New York and Albany. — Interven- tion of the G. L. U. S. — The revival of the Order, and its new organi- zation.— James Alcock, G. M. — The Order firmly established. — Reflec- tion on the new birth. — John A. Kennedy. — ^Wilson Small. CHAPTER XVII. Odd Fellowship in Pennsylvania, 427 Introduction— Pennsylvania Lodge instituted. — Its officers. — It accepts a charter from the G. L. of Md. and of the U. S. — John Upton. — Dock Street. — John Pearce. — New Jersey. — The case of James Day. — John Xiy CONTENTS. PAS] B. Robinson and Samuel Croucher.— Penn. Lodge, No. 1.— The sub- ordinate lodges during the first dccade.~Wa8hington Lodge, No. 2. Account of an ancient lodge meeting.— Wayne Lodge, No. 8.— Morn- ing Star Lodge, No. 4.— Franklin Lodge, No. 6.— General Marion Lodge, No. 6.— Hermann Lodge, No. 7.— Rising Sun Lodge, No. 8. Meclianics' Lodge, No. 9.— Philomathean Lodge, No. 10.— Kensing- ton Lodge, No. 11.— JeflTerson Lodge, No. 12.— Philadelphia Lodge, No. 18.— Wildey Lodge, No. 14— Philanthropic Lodge, No. 15.— Har- mony Lodge, No. 16.— Northern Liberty Lodge, No. 17.— La Fayette Lodge, No. 18.— Amity Lodge, No, 19, and Miners' Lodge, No. 20.— Reflections. CHAPTER XVIII. Thb Gband Lodqb of Pbknsylvakia. 468 The first in national importance. — Its charter. — Aaron Nichols, G. M. and Wui. H. Matthews, G. Sec — ^Be^jamin Daffin. — ^Aaron Nichols. Thomas Small, G. M.— Samuel Pryor.— William H. Matthews, G. M. Jolm G. Potts.— Official report in 1829 to G. L. U. S., and corres- pondence of Grand Officers. — Report at the end of first decade. — An- niversaries.— ^The new Hall on South Fifth Street. — Its dedication. — Comparison between Pcnn. and the other States. — Pennsylvania always led the column. — Succeeded without Wildey's assistance. The secret of its success, and the men who have made it triumphant. Conclusion. CHAPTER XIX. Thb District of Colttmbia. . 484 Central Lodge, No. 1. — Its offlcxirs and first initiates. — Georgetown Lodge, No. 1 — James Gettys and others initiated-«-Rev. Lorenzo Dow. Petition for G. Lodge granted. — Thos. M, Abbett, G. M. — Concord Loilge, No. 8. — James Gettys, G. M. — Jonathan Lodge, No. 4. — Poca- hontas Lodge. — The decline of the lodges, and its cause. — A counter movement. — Central Lodge resuscitated. — A great Hall for the Or- der.— Thomas M. Abbett and James Gettys. CHAPTER XX. Thb Theory of the Degrees. (Hlustratcd) 495 The secrets of Odd Fellowship. — Its doctrines not esoteric. — The foim- dation of the I. O. O. F.— Analysis of the theory of our secret work. The plan for its exemplification. — The rationale of the degrees of the Bubonlinate lodge, and their extension in the Encampment branch. — Exemplification of the degrees.— The first degree.— The second de- gree.—The third degree.— The fourth degree.— The fifth degree.— The end of the degrees.— The Patriarchal Degree.— The Golden Rule Degree.— The Royal Purple D^ree.— The end. ENGRAVINGS. STEEL I'AaE. I .» -y I.— JAS. L. RIDGELY, G. C. and R. Sbgbbtary. Frontittpitce. ^ n.— THOMAS WILDEY, P. G. Siue 275 in.— JOHN A. KENNEDY, \\ G. Sikk 415 rV.— JAMES GETTY8, P. G. Sike 493 t ' . r WOOD. I.— THE SEVEN STARS, Baltimore, 1819, 15 IL— THE THREE LOGGERHEADS, Baltimore, 1821. . . 37 in.— PLAN OF WASHINGTON LODGE-ROOM, 1819. . . 4.5 IV.— COLVIN'S STONE TAVERN, Baltimore, 1823. . . 53 v.— JOHN BOYD .57 VI.-JOHN WELCH .101 VII.— WILDEY'S HOUSE, Baltimore, 1824 14.3 Vm.— L 0.0. F. HALL, Gay St., Baltimore, 1831-1859. . 147 fc ^^^^i^, IX,— AUGUSTUS MATHIOT 149 * X,— RICHARD MARLEY 101 ., XL— JOHN PAWSON ENTWISLE 237 XII.— WILDEY MONUMENT, Baltimore 294 XIIL— TOMB OF WILDEY, Baltimore 295 ? fJ \ XIV.— JAMES B. BARNES :m ^ XV.— ENGLISH MEDAL PRESENTED TO JAS. B. BARNES. . 3:17 XVI.— EATON'S HOUSE, Boston, 1820 3:i» XVII.— AMERUWN MEDAL PRESENTED TO JAS. B. BARNES. JUl XVIIL— JAMES WOOD :W5 XIX.— THOMAS BARR ;«7 XX.— MASONIC HALL, Akn St., Boston, 1S2:{ 3«() XXL— DANIEL HERSEY 308 r ^ XVI CONTENTS. % '^ 1849 -/ 4 t 1 XXTI.— ALBERT GUILD XXIIL— L O. O. F. HALL, Washington St., Boston, 1864. XXIV.— L O. O. F. HALL, Tremont St., Boston, 1871. . XXV.— ECLIPSE AND SIR HENRY, New Yokk, 1823. X XXVI.— BENJAMIN DOWNING. . . ' . XXVIL— WILSON SMALL XXVIIL— I. O. O. F. HALL, Grand and Centre Sts., N. York, XXIX— UPTONS HOTEL, Philadelphia, 1821. . XXX.— JOHN UPTON ^ XXXI.— JOHN PEARCE XXXH.- BENJAMIN DAFFIN XXXIIL— THE NICHOLS MONUMENT, Chambersburcj XXXIV.— THOMAS SMALL. XXXV.— SAAIUEL PRYOR XXXVI.— L O. O. F. HALL, South Fifth St., PniL.u>ELriiiA, 1830. XXXVII.— L O. O. F. HALL, Sixth and Crewsun Sts.\ Phila., 1840. XXXVIIL— L O. O. F. HALL, Broad and Sp\i Garden Sts., Phila., 1852 XXXIX.— MILBURN'S HOTEL, Washington, 1827. XL.— LIBRARY BUILDING, Wa8Hin(ston, 1828 XLI.— THOMAS M. ABBETT. XLIL— I. O. O. F. HALL, Washington, 1874. XLin.— THE ALL SEEING EYE. . XLIV.— THE SUN AND SCYTHE. . XLV.— THE BOW AND ARROWS. XLVI.— THE ARK OF THE COVENANT, XLVII.— THE GLOBE AND LAMB. XLVIII.— THE BIBLE AND COFFIN. XLIX.— THE H. P. AND G. OF T. . L.— THE THREE PILLARS. . LI.— THE TABLES OF STONE. LII.— SCRIP, SANDALS AND STAFF. PAQE. 387 ;^88 3J)2 395 41(S 422 423 425 42(5 4(>1 4^3 4(^4 4fr) 477 478 . 479 480 484 4H6 490 498 499 500 501 503 503 504 5a5 500 507 CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION. But how tho Bubject-theme may gang. Let time and chance determine ; Ferliaiw It may turn out a sang, Porhape turn out a eermon. —BrRsa. " It is the first law of liistory, that tlie writer should neither dare to advance what is false nor to suppress what is true ; that he should relate the facts with strict impartiality, free from ill will or favor; that his narrative should distinguish the order of time, and, when necessary, the description of places ; that he should imfold the motives of men, and in his account of the transactions or the events, interj^ose his own judgment : should relate what was done, how it was done, and what share chance, rashness, or pnidence had in the issue; that he should give the character of the leading men, their weiglit and influence, their passions, principles, and conduct through life." Cicero was never more fortunate than when, witli peculiar felicity of diction, he wrote this heautiful canon of criticism. Its conception and expression would seem to defy any later censor to add to or diminish from its scope and substance, and render it worthy to appear with the golden sentences engraved upon the memory of the world. The rule indicates deep insight, and is suitable to any age and every historian. As our ability may serve, we shall consult this chart in the work before us, and strive to present it in such lights and with BXU'h accessories as will give the reader a true version of the matter. We shall be at pains also to leave the common track of €ulog}', and to deal with impartial measure tlie praise and blame due to prominent individuals; omitting no incident that may ser\'e to shed light upon the eventful story. A growing desire has for some time prevailed on the part of Odd FelloMs, that the origin of the Order should l)e dertnitt^ly 1 AMERICAN ODD FELLOWSHIP. and authoritatively declared, and that its career should be traced from the beginning. Such a desire is natural, and ought to be gratified. True, in many instances this sentiment will be found to be rather the aspiration of a noble pride, than the demand of the mind for a discussion of the principles with which we are identified. To gratify such laudable feelings would at all times be a pleasant task ; but such is not our only design. The sine qua 7wn of the Order is not merely that we should indulge in nnitual congratulations. The primary demand of the communi- ties upon which its principles are designed to act, and even of Odd Fellows themselves, is indeed of far greater moment ; the latter require it for tlieir justification and encouragement, and the former for their enlightenment and co-operative favor. These can only be furnished by its character and reliability as an agent for good among men. By the force of circumstances it has already been grandly advertised ; its practical public life and its jibundant fruits during the last half century have left Imt little to present which is really new. The incidents of its origin have been sown broadcast by itij orators and its publications, and by the favorable notices of the press ; many of these have been highly colored, and some of them are entirely apocrj^hal ; yet out of this partial chaos, one may easily perceive a lofty pedestal, with glimpses of an angel hand removing the veil from a statue of exquisite symmetry and beauty. Odd Fellowship, as we know it, is an institution of modem times, grown in our midst and fashioned by our liands. Every brother who has been impressed with its principles, who has observed its influence upon men, or has been led to investigate and dis(*over its true character, knows its origin, the manner of its introduction into this country, — wheny vhere^ and hy ithom^ — and also its general (career up to this day. He is, besides, thoroughly advised of the changes it has undergone under American auspices. The principles, however, of the Order are of early date, and go back to periods of time when men were under very different guidance — religious, moral, and intel- lectual. Indeed, the relation of fraternity, instinctive of human- ity and divinity, w'as the birth-right of the rdce ; innate as life itself is the sentiment of a (x>mmon father and a single family, that we are "of one blood," and that each son of Adam is my brother by hereditary ties. Such also have been the a\vfiil and splendid INTRODUCTTION. announcements of revelation, by which we know the eternal God as the Father of mankind. From these sources, Odd Fellowship, as a system of fraternal benevolence and reciprocal aid, comprehending not only its prin- ciples, but its illustrative and theoretical character, is derived. Like many other institutions, it has blended beautiful ceremonies with solid and useful forms ; these, though harmless, may be thought superfluous and of no efficient value. But whether in- dulged in as agreeable ornaments, or relied upon as necessary and improving adjuncts, they are an interesting feature in the sub- stantive administration of the system. This, far from being pecu- liar to Odd Fellows, is characteristic of all delicately organized association, of all classes of people, in fact of nature itself. Nothing in life is presented in its simple and exclusively neces- sary apparel ; everything is decked in engaging colors, so as to combine attractiveness and beauty with utility and value. Some- thing, however, may be necessary, as well to vindicate it from attempted disparagement in other respects, as to a proper enlight- enment of the public mind. Odd Fellowship is sometimes spoken of reproachfully by reason of its name, on account of the seeming levity it conveys. It is also not unfrequently taunted as a bor- '4^ rower, and thus having nothing in its organization which is orig- inal, having derived everything of consequence in its system and ritual from other sources, particularly so from the Masonic Order. For some years during its earlier career, such unjust as well as ungenerous imputations obtained ; but for the most part it has outlived such reproaches, and conquered by its works the general good favor. Touching the name, it may be replied, that if not euphonious, that fact is wholly unimportant so long as the object in \'iew is honorable and worthy, even should such a name not be appropriate as fully indicative of its purpose. An objection on this point is equally wanting in force, for tlie reason that fit- ness in the mere selection of a name is rather the exception than the rule ; taste, caprice, and sometimes even prejudice, generally determining the choice. That great body of Christians known as Methodists, was so nicknamed by its enemies ; and that valuable class of citizens known as Quakers, was so chIIcmI in tlie first instance as a mark of scorn and ridicule. Yet those bodies liave turned the tables on their adversaries, bv answering to those names as a mark of the honorable circumstances under which -li 4 AMERICAN ODD FELLOWSHIP. they were first imposed. In like manner we may point to the first occasion for our name in the good fellowship that has ripened into a blessed fraternity, among boon companions and the fumes of beer and tobacco, in the convivial companionship of homeless tramps and bustling landlords ; but all tliese have been forgotten. As to our principles and ceremonies, these we are willing to admit rest upon a common basis with those of other secret societies. We have the same grand natural truths and the same splendid revelation. History with its magnificent examples and glorious illustrations is the common property of all, and it is only because we have dug in the same mines that the precious jewels that we wear are so very similar. Having the same base, they are of the same species. All avail themselves of like means of inter-communication and recognition, viz. a language of signs and symbols ; all aspire to an important and moral agency in promoting closer relations among men, and in the elevation of the race; but it by no means follows that Odd Fellowship derives its character from Masonry, or is a borrower from its ritual. Successive offspring of fraternity, they each bear the stamp of their common origin ; but as well say that brothers by blood are copies of each other because of their resemblance to the common parent, as that Odd Fellowship is a recast of Masonry. Had signs and symbols, or the application of them to language, been originated by our sister Order, or had tlie Divine Wisdom, in making fraternity obligatory, committed its administration to her, we should at once concede the claims of the indis- creet advocates who assume such a position. But as the fact is far otherwise, we cannot go further in deferring to her claim in this regard, than cheerfully to accord her greater antiquity in the inculcation of universal truth, and of practical benevolence among men as a paramount duty. Odd Fellows recognize Free Masonry as an eminent, honorable and useful institution ; but they also claim a just measure of respect at its hands, and press upon it a fraternal challenge for supremacy "in tlie warfare which they wage against vice in all its forms," and invite it to raise the Masonic standard still liigher if it can. True to their lessons, we have every reason to believe that a corresponding sympathy prevails among our Masonic brethren, and tliat henceforth tlie only conflict between these two great organiza- tions, enlisted in the interest of humanity, will be an earnest INTBODUOnON. 5 rivalry as to which shall achieve the noblest record in so grand a cause. But assailants, who are alike inimical to Masonry and to Odd Fellowship, and to all other organizations of men for benevolent purposes, which are secret, still remain. They are of two classes ; the first has neither character nor influence, but drives a mercenary trade by the sale of so called exposures of the rites and ceremonies of these orders. They may well be left to the degrar dation of the lot they have chosen : w^hether they have swindled the orders or the public is a small matter ; in either case they are swindlers, and from such no possible harm can happen to honorable men. The other class is far different, and is armed with an authority which multitudes acknowledge and obey. We refer to certain portions of the Christian Church. So far as our order was con- cerned, this was originally the greatest obstacle in the way. By reason of a mistaken view of our character and objects, we found in the churches bitter and uncompromising enemies. But the Protestant Churches, that live in the light of an intel- ligent public opinion, gradually changed their ground, and made honorable amends for their original position, so that for the most part they now give us substantial aid and comfort. We shall not waste words in discussing the hostility of the Eoman Catholic Church to all secular secret societies. That establishment is so exclusive and dictatorial that it cannot brook apparent opjx)- sition, even in the strife of good works. Its system of central, arbitrary and exclusive authority cannot admit our independent efforts ; but the loss is not ours, and confident in our work and destiny, we may well afford to pity a perversity which cuts off its members from one of the greatest lights of civilization. But they do not altogether grope in darkness ; to the contrary, we discover everywhere arising among them H\moB>t /ac-fiimiles of our secret societies, aiming to borrow our forms and regalia, and scarcely to be distinguished by the public from Masons or Odd Fellows. Such is the compliment paid us by our worst traducers, and surely we can ask nothing more. Secret benevo- lent societies are as old as any Christian Church, and in fac^t owe their origin to religion. Such associations have never checked or injured any fonn of goodness. Our order is composed of men of wdely differing religious and political opinions, and is acces- sible at all times and in all places to the press and to the people. 9 AMERICAN ODD FELLOWSHIP. Under such conditions its most secret recesses are made bare, and adequate security given, were any necessary, for tlie public safety. An attack, therefore, upon our secrecy is of a piece with the rest, an ebullition of public envy or of private spite. Secular organizations for benevolence, whose mission is to the masses, and whose work lies in " visiting the sick, succoring the widow, caring for the afflicted, burying the dead, and educating the orphan," seriously interfere wuth those who exclusively assume such duties " by divine right," and yet fail fully and properly to discharge them. The citizen organization which enters upon and discharges these duties is a standing menace to infallibility. "7/tW UhB lachryvioi!^'* The anathema is therefore not so much aimed at our secrecy as against our good works, and their tendency to interfere with peculiar religious dogmas. But we turn to a brighter side of the picture. The object of this work is to present before the world one of those great organizations as w^orthy of confidence and respect as an agent of general benefacv tion. We feel assured that by a diffusion of a correct knowledge of its labors and of their fruits during the last half century, its usefulness will not only be greatly promoted, but a new and powerful impulse will be supplied to its increasing growth and resources. Its history will be written under the influence of that sentiment. It will therefore require that we consider and present the true origin, commencing as an assemblage of workmen in England for social enjoyment, and its transition from an inchoate beginning to a formal association ; its continued development to a system having defined objects ; thence the formation of Lodges, and to a combination of these into an affiliated Order, in imita- tion no doul>t of kindred existing establishments, the first being known as "The Ancient Order of Odd Fellows," begun in the city of London in the 17th century. We shall also introduce all that is known of the colonization of these principles on our shores: that emigrants from England planted the seeds of the enteq)rise ; that they were representatives of the various classes or divisions of the Order in the mother country, which were wholly independent (»f each other, and differed entirely in their svstems of work. Such dissimilar elements could not, however, hannonize ; and thus their Odd Fellowship, although of a kindred origin, was, INTKODUCTION. T when blended, merely patchwork, made up of the ritual of several of those independent societies. But the American Order was fortunate. It will appear that by the accidental visit of a brother better instructed, they were furnished with later and more complete information, which gave them unity. So far as hecould recognize anything among them, he found a singular mixture ; being a jumble and compound of the Union Order, and of the London or Ancient Order. But by his assistance these were discarded for the true and established work of the Manchester Unity. But these accidental lodges will be found to have nothing in common with our Order, which had its origin in Thomas Wildey in 1819. From this point it will be traced to the year 1833 inclu- sive, showing its gradual change of character, and consequent adaptation to lofty moral results. As a system created under American auspices, it has a record which it will be our effort faithfully to portray. Taking it up in that aspect, on the 26th of April, 181J), the day of its birth in the city of Baltimore, by the institution of Washington I^dge, No. 1, we shall unfold the true story of its iirst planting. The Grand Lodge of the United States has never recognized any besides the four originals, in their natural order, namely : Washington I^dge, No. 1, of Maryland; Massachusetts Lodge, No. 1, of Massachusetts; Columbia Lodge, No. 1, of New York, and Pennsylvania Lodge, No. 1, of Pennsylvania. The first of these succeeded in bringing the others into a common union, and in that way formed the nucleus of the present Order. Tlie first movers were of limited education, and in a humble sphere of life. At a later period the Order acquired men of education from every calling in life, many of whom testified their love for the institution bv the most valuable assistance of mind and body in its behalf; but these were restrained by a proper delicacy from magnifying their own achievements. They came in generally after the first decade, and to them we are mainly indebted for what may properly be called moral and progres- sive Odd Fellowship. They found it simply a beneficial so- ciety, presenting nothing attractive; and to their sagacity and enlightened judgment is due the combination of the moral and beneficial features of the Order, and the blending of the two into the one great idea of the American system. To accomplish this, it became necessary to engraft higher aspirations upon the orig- 8 AMERICAN ODD FELLOWSHIP. inal stock, to widen the scope of its ambition, to amplify tlio- moral area, and to lift it into a higher and purer region. They could not speak of these things but in the first person and ^' quorum para fuV^ was not their motto. No records of the Grand Lodge of the United States had been preserved for several years after its separation from {he Grand Lodge of Maryland, nor had the minutes, after separating from Washington Lodge, been more than a mere skeleton, and that belonged to the Grand Lodge of Maryland. Nor had the Grand Lodge of Maryland any printed journal anterior to 1831, and it is only since then that its proceedings have been published. The Grand Lodge of the United States was in fac^t without any authentic manuscript record of its own proceedings, and had no printed minutes, except occasional detached sheets, up to 1827. The manuscript journals of the earlier period of Maryland, Penn- sylvania, New York, and possibly of Massachusetts, now in exist- ence, have been since collected and printed. It became neces- sary to supply this deficiency, in the best way it could be done, before it was too late. Accordingly the G. L. U. S., whose atten- tion was called to this subject by the Grand Secretar}^ at the ses- sion of 1841, directed that officer to obtain from P. G. Sire Wildey all " documents connected with the early history of the Order in his possession ; comprising ancient chartei*s, pamphlets, magazines and record books of much interest and valuable infor- mation "; also, " to collect all property of this Grand Lodge, now in possession of others, and retain the same in his possession until a depository may be provided, or as this Grand Lodge may direct." It was also further ordered " that the Grand Corresponding and Recording Secretary, be and he is hereby authorized to rent a suitable room as a place of deposit for all the books, documents and property of the Grand Lodge of the United States, and to transfer to said room the said property, after he shall have made an inventory thereof." At the session of 1842, it was " Resolved, that the Grand Lodge of the United States approve of the printing of the journal from the commencement, in case any respectable member of the Order shall feel disposed to do so, on his own account ; in which event the Grand Lodge will subscribe for one hundred copies " ; and also, "that the Grand Secretary be and he is hereby ap- pointed to revise and cause to be published a correct journal of INTRODUCTION. 9 the proceedings of this Lodge from its formation, provided the same be of no expense to the Grand Body." (Journal, 502.) These proceedings were all in the interest of progress, and led to the most valuable results ; while the necessity for them indi- cates the very loose manner in which business had been con- ducted, there being at that late day no proper office for the Grand Secretary nor depository for the archives, and in fact no record or account books, and no system of any kind. This measure of reform was indispensable and wise, and was the begin- ning of that system which has caused the subsequent proceedings of the Order to take their present comprehensive and luminous form. In pursuance thereof the Grand Secretary selected Bro. John A. Kennedy of New York, then Grand Sire, as his assistant in this interesting business. By their joint labors and persistent research, all of the first volume of the revised journal was ob- tained : that is to say, the record of the organization of the Grand Lodge of Maryland and of the United States, and the detail of proceedings from that initial to the formation of the Grand Lodge of tlie United States ; also, the pre-history of the several subordinate Lodges out of which it was formed, with the records of the four State Grand Lodges until their union with the present federal system. This invaluable record was obtained in detached portions, in part from the manuscript journal of Washington Lodge, No. 1, the minutes of the Grand Lodge of Marjland and of the United States, and of the Grand Lodges of Pennsylvania, New York, and Massachusetts. To these were added traditionary data obtained from the leading men who took part in the early movements, and who had not then passed away. This material was woven into the text of the first volume of the journal from 1821 to 1826 inclusive, and furnished the copious notes thereto appended. There seems to have been an utter indifference to the preservation of the early records, so much BO indeed that many of the original minute-books of the first Lodges were permitted to perish. The result of all these in- quiries and of all this research terminated in the book that was reported to the G. L. U. S. at the session of 1844, and was adopte